Make a Reservation

Il bisogno si conosce l'amico.

You know a true friend when in need.

By Pamela Lewy

Sweeet Pies Places in NYC!

Who doesn’t love pie? Pie is great no matter what – but we love them most during the holidays – fresh, hot and filled with all of the delicious fillings that are so abundant in the fall like pumkin, apples, pears. Here’s our list of Pie shops in the city that allow you to enjoy them year-round, without ever having to turn your oven on.

New York Pie Company
322 E. 59th St. New York
NY 10022 Phone
(212) 269-7437

New York Pie Company has an extensive array of pies, cheesecakes, assorted Baked goods and espresso drinks, all made fresh on the premises. Scott Izratty and Daniel Rienzo, Queens natives, own this tiny 10-foot-by-28-foot store. In addition to basic cheesecakes, New York Pie Company sells many other kinds – including Black Forest, pineapple and Oreo – in two sizes: 7 inches (6 to 8 slices) and 11-inches (14 to 16 slices). Prices for 10-inch apple, blueberry, cherry and peach crumb pies range from $13.25 to $14.25 – right now they have pumpkin pie!

Little Pie Company

407 W 14th St
New York, NY 10014
(212) 414-2324
(877) 872-PIES

It’s no wonder that since 1985, people from all over the world have been sniffing out the comforting, simple pleasures wafting from the ovens of the Little Pie Company, a friendly oasis of warm country goodness in the heart of Manhattan.

They ship pies all over and even have sugarless pies! All pies are fresh, not frozen and are made without any use of chemicals. No wonder everyone loves them!

Eileen’s Special Cheescake
(ok, maybe its not technically pie, but it’s too good to leave off the list)

17 Cleveland Pl New York
NY 10012-4052
(212) 966-5585

You have to fight all temptations not to go… The cheesecake is so delicious, you just have to! If you’re feeling too guilty you can buy mini cheesecakes for one serving here in a variety of flavors. They also offer mail order.